A buyers’ guide to hybrids and electric vehicles

A buyers’ guide to hybrids and electric vehicles
A buyers’ guide to hybrids and electric vehicles

As diesel sales decline, registrations of alternatively fuelled vehicles (AFVs) have soared. In 2018 141,234 were sold – a 20 per cent rise on 2017 – and a significant growth given that the total car market shrank by 6.8 per cent per cent.

Despite their growth, AFVs, including hybrids and electric vehicles (EVs) are still a small proportion of all car sales – around 5.9 per cent. Surveys repeatedly find that drivers are confused and unsure about much of the terminology around the cars and about their capabilities.

This guide aims to address some of that confusion and help you decide if an AFV is right for you by breaking down the differences, strengths and weaknesses of each type of AFV.

There are three main types of AFVs – serial hybrids (also sometimes called self-charging or simply hybrid), plug-in hybrids (PHEV) and pure electric vehicles (EV). Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles are also AFV but still in their infancy with only two models actually on sale in the UK.

Serial hybrids

Series-parallel hybrids pair a traditional internal combustion engine (ICE) with an electric motor and a small battery. Examples include the Toyota Prius and Corolla, Hyundai Ioniq hybrid and Kia Niro and Mini Countryman PHEV.

The engine and motor can work together or in isolation depending on the requirements and the system uses energy diverted from the engine or regenerative braking to charge the battery.

Some manufacturers describe these as self-charging as the hybrid system replenishes the battery without the need to plug it in but some EV campaigners have taken offence at this because the battery is charged by an engine that burns petrol.

Pros

  • Potentially high economy
  • Good value for business buyers
  • No range anxiety

Cons

  • Very short EV-only range
  • No longer eligible for government grant
  • Expensive compared with ICE equivalent

These hybrids have a very short range using just the electric motor – usually only a few miles. The motor is there mostly to support the engine and offer greater performance with relatively low emissions and fuel use.

These hybrids are attractive to business buyers thanks to their low CO2 emissions, which have a positive effect on Benefit in Kind tax costs. They also offer good economy if driven correctly, giving potentially greater range than an equivalent ICE car.

Series hybrids are a good fit for drivers looking to reduce running costs and emissions without sacrificing performance or driving range and who don’t want to worry about charging infrastructure.

Plug-in hybrids

These work on a similar basis to self-charging hybrids but feature a far larger battery pack. Example include the Mitsubishi Outlander PHEV, Hyundai Ioniq PHEV, Volvo XC90 T8 Twin Engine and BMW 330e.

While most self-chargers can do fewer than five miles in EV mode, the latest PHEVs can cover up to 30 miles on battery power and can be driven at motorway speeds in EV mode.

PHEVs charge their batteries via regenerative braking and engine charging but can also be charged via dedicated power points or even a home plug socket. Depending on the rate of charge these can take between 25 minutes and five hours to fully replenish an average PHEV’s battery.

Some manufacturers will contribute to the price of a home charger, which will usually be a 7kW “fast” charger, and there is a £500 government grant to help cover the cost.

Pros

  • Better EV range than serial hybrids
  • Option to charge via private and public charge points
  • No range anxiety thanks to ICE

Cons

  • Small EV range compared to BEVs
  • Ideally need access to home charger
  • Complexity of hybrid systems

PHEVs benefit from huge economy claims thanks to the way they perform in testing. You will probably never see 170mpg in real life but the lab figures do allow them to fall into favourable emissions and tax brackets for business buyers, and they offer better economy than equivalent ICE cars thanks to the opportunity to run in electric-only mode.

However, their complex hybrid systems do mean there are more parts to go wrong and potentially expensive bills if they need specialist repairs.

PHEVs are a good choice for drivers who want to complete mid-distance drives with a low environmental impact but regularly need the flexibility and range of an ICE.

EVs

The furthest removed from “traditional” cars. EVs use one or more large electric motors to drive their wheels, drawing power from a large battery. Examples include Tesla’s whole model range, the Nissan Leaf, Audi e-tron, Kia e-Niro, Jaguar I-Pace and VW e-Golf.

EVs offer a number of benefits over ICE cars as well as some drawbacks. They produce zero tailpipe emissions, are quieter and smoother and have fewer moving parts, which mean there’s less to go wrong and they’re cheaper to service.

Buyers of new models are also eligible for a grant of up to £3,500 as well as the £500 charger contribution. However, EVs remain more expensive than a similar sized ICE car.

For many drivers range anxiety remains the big worry with an EV. The good news is that some of the latest models, such as the Hyundai Kona Electric and Kia e-Niro offer genuine range of more than 200 miles on a charge while many others achieve real-world distances of 120-150 miles.

While that is a problem if you regularly do long distances, government data shows the average British driver covers less than 5,700 miles a year, which equates to just 15 miles a day. The RAC Foundation estimates that the average drive to work is just under 10 miles, so a daily two-way trip is well within the range of any new EV.

More public charging points are being added every week. (Picture: Shutterstock)

The other worry remains around infrastructure. For commuters planning to charge at home or work this isn’t a serious matter but for drivers undertaking longer drives they need to know there is a reliable network of chargers. The good news is that there are already 11,000 chargers at 6,700 locations in the UK and that number is rising all the time.

Charging costs do vary, however. According to a What Car? investigation, charging a 40kW car with around 130 miles of range from zero to 80 per cent charge will cost around between £2 and £4 at home but up to £17 at the most expensive public chargers.

Pros

  • Zero tailpipe emissions
  • Low running and repair costs
  • Refinement

Cons

  • Charging times
  • Can’t match ICE maximum range
  • Expensive

The biggest drawback of EVs remains the charging time. With the common 7kW home charger a 40kW Nissan Leaf will take 7.5 hours to reach full, a 64kW Kona will take just over nine hours. At the most common 50kW rapid chargers, a Leaf takes 60 minutes to reach 80 per cent and a Kona around 75 minutes. That means long journeys will take longer and require more planning than in an ICE vehicle.

EVs are far more capable than even a few years ago and are now a viable option for many drivers looking to cut their environmental impact and running costs significantly. They are ideally suited as a commuter car as long as you have access to a charge point but drivers who regularly cover very long distances might struggle with the compromise in range and “refuelling” time.

The best cars for young families - SUVs and MPVs compared

Driven to distraction: Are safety tech features in cars actually making them more dangerous?